GUIDELINES FOR READERS OF MANUSCRIPTS

Thank you for agreeing to assess the attached manuscript – your comments will be extremely useful in helping us to assess the quality of the project in terms of scholarship. 

With your permission, we would like to be able to share the contents of your report with the author. Please, indicate whether you would prefer us to include/delete your personal details and/or paraphrase your report or not. We will not reveal your name without your express permission under any circumstances.  

Please do not spend time correcting spelling or grammatical errors, as those will be fixed in the copyediting phase of production. 
 
TITLE:
AUTHOR/EDITOR:

YOUR NAME:
ACADEMIC ADDRESS (including country):
EMAIL:
PREFERRED MAILING ADDRESS (if different than above):

Would you allow us to extract comments from your report for promotional purposes, including your name and institution?

Yes:
No:

1: What is your overall opinion of this manuscript?

2: Do you feel that conceptual and methodological concerns are appropriately addressed or would you recommend a reassessment of these concerns?

3: In terms of content do you think that the manuscript needs any revisions? (e.g. additions, omissions)

4: Do you think that the proposed structure needs any revisions? A key question is the length of the proposed manuscript.

5: Does the research presented appear to adhere to the ethical standards of the discipline? Are informant identities blurred where appropriate? Does the author discuss appropriate methodological steps to protect participants? 

6: In which disciplinary areas would the main and subsidiary interest in this manuscript occur?

7: What do you consider to be the main markets for this manuscript? (i.e. academic, postgraduate, undergraduate, general interest)

8: Who do you consider to be the main purchasers for this manuscript? (i.e. individual academics, individual students, central libraries, department libraries)

9: If the work is likely to be useful for students, for what courses and at what levels might it be useful?

10: Do you envision the work being an essential purchase or recommended reading for students, or neither?

11: Are you aware of any other material that is appropriate for the same course/purpose as this manuscript (either forthcoming or already available)? If you are, please supply details of title, author, publisher (where known) and any other comments e.g. strengths and weaknesses.

12: Do you think the proposed length seems appropriate for the topic and readership?

13: Is the author’s style appropriate for the intended market?

14: Is the title/subtitle appropriate for the intended market?

15: Please, outline any points you may have regarding possible international sales (i.e. countries, course, level, need for case studies etc.).

16: What is your overall recommendation?

17: Do you have any other points not covered by this questionnaire?

Very many thanks for taking the time to answer these questions. Your assistance is much appreciated. Please, let us know whether you prefer a fee of $200/£125 or Berghahn ebooks to the value of $350/£225 (after 35% author’s discount where applicable). If you wish to receive books, please browse the complete listing of our titles on our website at www.berghahnbooks.com, and send us the list of selected titles.